About - All Star Car Rentals

At Allstar Car Rentals, our mission is simple: to redefine car rental service with personalized, face-to-face pick-up and drop-off services that go beyond expectations.

Our Journey: From Humble Beginnings to a Vision Realized

Starting in 2012 with just a few cars, we listened closely to our customers, understanding their need for convenient, reliable rental services that worked around their schedule and location. This insight drove us to create a service tailored to the needs of our customers.

Our unwavering vision fueled our growth, and our commitment to delivering personalized, exceptional experiences has remained constant.

As we expand and innovate, we stay deeply connected to our local community, grateful for the support of our valued customers and partners.

Check This Out

Our Clients Absolutely Adore Us

Our clients rave about our swift and seamless process, exceptional customer service, and our willingness to go the extra mile—like assisting with luggage. With our agents meeting customers at designated locations, whether at the airport or their accommodations, we eliminate wait times entirely. They also consistently praise the top-notch quality of vehicles in our fleet, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable experience from start to finish.

“

We used All Star Car Rental…..awesome! Waiting for us when we got off the plane, signed paperwork and we were on our way. When we returned to the airport we left vehicle in the parking lot. Would definitely use them again.
Cheryl BConnecticut, USA

“

They were recommended to us by the Discovery Point Club where we have stayed for the last three years. They met us at the airport with the vehicle, we completed the paperwork on the spot and they met us at the airport on our departure to pick the vehicle up once again at the airport. The vehicle was exactly as ordered, clean, in good repair and overall met our needs. It was a right hand drive however that did not pose any difficulties for us once we got used to it. I would certainly recommend them.
Hunter DuneAncaster, Canada

“

We just got back from a Thanksgiving trip and used All Star. Oscar is amazing! He was waiting for us even though our plane was very delayed. We rented a large van due to our group size and luggage. Later in the week, the air conditioning had a small issue. Oscar brought a replacement car to us literally in 5 minutes from when we called him. We will definitely be going with All Star next time!
LuceeWilmington

“

We were recommended All Star car rental, which I have never heard of but trusted the lady in charge. They were pleasant to deal with, way cheaper than what I paid at Hertz every time and any questions or problems they followed right up and the car and the keys were waiting for us as soon as we checked into condo. Plus they took the taxi ride off the total price, I hate dealing with the car rental companies and walking over there, so I found it to be rather nice and way easier.
wfpmiThe Woodlands, Texas

“

We've always used All Star Car Rental. This trip they went above and beyond as our flight was delayed over 2 hrs then stuck in customs line. They stayed till close to 8 pm at the airport to meet us. Super easy and fast to use.
BR35CanuckCanada

“

This summer, we traveled to the Cayman Islands with a large family group and rented two minivans from All Star Car Rental. The service was outstanding from start to finish, from the ease of booking online to the excellent staff. They were friendly, well-organized and incredibly responsive. I would highly recommend them for anyone looking for a reliable car rental service in the Cayman Islands.
Vacation01865965357Family

See All Google Reviews See All TripAdvisor Reviews

A Warm Welcome from the Owners of All Star Car Rentals

Hey there, Traveler!

We’re so excited to welcome you to the beautiful Cayman Islands! 🌴🌞

From the moment you touch down, we want you to know that you’re not just a visitor—you’re family. And here at All Star Car Rentals, we’re here to make sure your island adventure is everything you’ve dreamed of and more!

Need recommendations for the best hidden beaches or local hotspots? Want tips on where to grab the tastiest Caribbean bites? Or just need to know the quickest route to your next adventure? We’ve got your back. Think of us as your personal island guides, always ready to lend a helping hand (or a car key).

Our goal is simple: to make your trip hassle-free, full of memories, and totally unforgettable. We take care of the details so you can focus on having fun, relaxing, and soaking up the sun.
So, buckle up and let the good times roll! We can’t wait to meet you, hand you the keys to your ride, and be a part of your amazing journey.

Welcome to the Cayman Islands. Welcome to the All Star family! Safe travels and see you soon.

The All Star Car Rentals Family 🚗

Ready to start your journey? Browse our vehicles and book your adventure today!

Reserve a Vehicle

Terms & Conditions

Refund Policy

Partner Portal